Home Page ]   [ Hand Dyeing Top ]   [ Gallery Top ]   [ How to Dye ]   [ How to Tie Dye ]   [ How to Batik ]   [ Low Water Immersion Dyeing ]   [ Dip Dyeing ]   [ More Ideas ]   [ About Dyes ]   [ Sources for Supplies ]   [ Dyeing and  Fabric Painting Books ]   [ Links to other Galleries ]   [ Links to other informative sites ] [ Link pages ] [ Groups ] [ FAQs ]   [ Custom Dyers Listing ]   [ Link to this site ]   [ Dyeblog Q&A ]   [ search ]   [ contact me ]  

Paper Chromatography of Cold Water Fiber Reactive Dyes

(Experiment One - April 2, 2000)

Materials. Good quality blotter paper, tap water, pure dyes.

Methods. For each dye, a few grains of dye were mixed into one drop of cool tap water with a small weighing spatula, then used a dropper to place this on a penciled line drawn 2" from the bottom of a piece of good blotter paper. The paper was folded over one inch from the top. After drying, each page was hung in a box, across strings that had been stretched around the box, with at least 0.5 inch of paper sub merged, the dye spots well clear of the water. The water was allowed to creep up for one hour, until near the top of the paper, at which time the paper was removed and allowed to dry. The water continued to advance upwards on the page, so there are two drying lines marked at the top of the page in pencil. The paper were finally dried in an oven to stop the dye movement. A noteworthy detail is that the water temperature was hot - 130 Fahrenheit - which would tend to decrease the substantivity (affinity for cellulose) of the unreacted dye. Neither wetting agent nor fixative were added.

Results. The following images were scanned at 50 dpi.

The dyes in the chromatogram below are, left to right, navy MX-G (blue #9), blue MX-2G (slate or cobalt blue), blue MX-4GD, turquoise MX-G, and ProChem mixture Brilliant Blue #4224. It seems odd that the turquoise migrated such a short distance, when it seems to migrate very well on fabric [presumably due to its low reaction rate]. Note the distinct reddish halo above the blues for both MX-4RD. third from the left, and the ProChem Brilliant Blue mixture on the right. If blue MX-4RD is a mixture, what other blue is it made from? [conclusion: reddish stuff is not a dye]
scanned paper chromatogram of blues and turquoise cold water dyes

The dyes in the chromatogram below are, left to right, blue MX-7RX (blueviolet), blue MX-R (sky blue), blue F-GF (Cibacron F), blue MX-G (cerulean blue), and blue MX-3G (Aljo's turquoise number two). Note that the only blue that matches the migration seen in the ProChem mixture 4224 is blue MX-R. Since the concentrations of dyes were not standardized in this experiment, it is difficult to compare color intensity. There is no missing the bright reddish halo above the Cibacron F dye. It must not be 100% pure.[later conclusion: reddish stuff is not a dye; the dye is pure]
scanned paper chromatogram of other blue cold water dyes

The dyes below are, left to right, red MX-G, red MX-B, red MX-5B, red MX-8B, and violet MX-2R. It is quite surprising to see the fuchsia migrate farther than the violet, when the opposite is routinely observed when dyeing mixtures. [presumably this is because fuchsia reacts so quickly that its high rate of diffusion has no chance to show up.] The faint reddish hint above the violet might be due to a contaminating splatter of red MX-5B. [no probably the same reddish non-dye seen in the blues.]
scanned paper chromatogram of red cold water dyes

The dyes below are, left to right, yellow MX-8G, yellow MX-4G, yellow MX-GR, yellow MX-3RA, orange MX-2R, brown MX-GRN, and brown MX-5BR. Yellow MX-8G is the only dye in this series to migrate 100% as far as the water carrying it.
scanned paper chromatogram of yellow cold water dyes

Conclusions

None of the blue dyes are as mobile as the more mobile of the reds or yellows.

Turquoise MX-G has one of the lowest mobilities of all of the blue dyes, in the absence of sodium carbonate, reflecting its reputedly high molecular weight. (It is said to be a dimer of two dye molecules that are each similar in size to any of the other MX dyes.) Fuchsia does not have the low mobility that one would expect from experience in tie-dyeing and other direct dye application.

Should repeat experiment twice - once with cold dyes, no fixative, to better mimic low water immersion dyeing, and again in the presence of sodium carbonate, to better mimic tie-dyeing and dye painting conditions.



Copyright ©2000 Paula E. Burch, Ph.D.
All of the pages on this site are copyright ©1998-2024 Paula E. Burch, Ph.D. Anyone is welcome to repeat the experiments described on this page as closely as they like to the procedure given here as long as they properly reference this page in writing up their results; only the words and the images are copyrighted.


Home Page ]   [ Hand Dyeing Top ]   [ Gallery Top ]   [ How to Dye ]   [ How to Tie Dye ]   [ How to Batik ]   [ Low Water Immersion Dyeing ]   [ Dip Dyeing ]   [ More Ideas ]   [ About Dyes ]   [ Sources for Supplies ]   [ Dyeing and  Fabric Painting Books ]   [ Links to other Galleries ]   [ Links to other informative sites ] [ Link pages ] [ Groups ] [ FAQs ]   [ Custom Dyers Listing ]   [ Link to this site ]   [ Dyeblog Q&A ]   [ search ]   [ contact me ]  


Sitemeter says that there have been different visits to this site since May 5, 1999.

This page was last updated: April 2, 2000;
Downloaded at: Thursday, April 25, 2024, 10:47PM EDT